"Through our sunless lanes creeps Poverty with her hungry eyes, and Sin with his sodden face follows close behind her. Misery wakes us in the morning and Shame sits with us at night."
This quote is an excellent parallel to Angela's Ashes for so many reasons. The way Poverty, Sin, Misery, and Shame are personified can correlate to their roles within each member of the McCourt family. Poverty is the primary root of their misery, sin, and shame, though there are many factors at play. Shame takes the spotlight early on in the memoir when reflecting on Frank's conception and the fact that he was born out of wed-lock, something considered most disgraceful in the Irish culture where religion takes precedence. "They knew that Angela, unmarried, had no right to be in an interesting condition and they would take steps" (McCourt 15). It was also considered shameful that Angela, from the South of Ireland, was to marry a man from northern Ireland. Throughout the novel the sectional, ethnic, and religious differences are glaring and not taken lightly. A person from Ireland is not just Irish: they are northern, southern, Protestant, or Catholic and you simply don't associate with those that are not of the same classification as you. "...He was a disgusting specimen but what could you expect from the North of Ireland" (18).
Shame is a motif weaving through most aspects of the novel, especially caused by Malachy's severe drinking problem, which brings shame to the entire McCourt family. Malachy is clearly aware of his out-of-control behavior and the fact that he wastes his family's little money on the drink, and is ashamed of it, yet refuses to turn himself around. I believe that Malachy has been regarded as such a useless drunk for most of his life that he believes it and feels sorry for himself rather than taking the initiative to change his ways. "Uncle Pa says that's a disgraceful thing to do and Dad cries on his shoulder" (76).
Shame "sits with [the family] at night" as Angela and the children wait desperately for their father to return with some money, fully aware that he will not be home that night until every penny has been drained into a cup. McCourt refers to the drink as "the black stuff" to indicate how dark and damaging it has been to his life. "It's getting dark now and the coffin seems whiter than ever before in Dad's arms" (89). This quote contains an excellent comparison of innocence. Eugene's innocence, as symbolized by the whiteness of his coffin, has never been so prominent as when compared to his father. His father has made numerous mistakes and refuses to learn from them; he causes a great deal of the misery that his family is forced to suffer day in and day out.
McCourt's description of his childhood includes many dark and dreary images. "...What's the use of trying to make funny faces and letting things fall off your head when they can't see you in the dark?"(32). This theme of helplessness and misery is represented in various ways, especially the numerous references to flight and birds. "...The swings are frozen and won't even move" (29). McCourt wants to be free of his troubles but poverty and misery continually bring him down. Like they say, "you can't pull yourself up by the bootstraps when you don't have boots", and McCourt, through no fault of his own, has no boots. Sin, and shame, comes in to play when Frank steals bananas from a store to feed his hungry, crying baby brothers. "But what am I to do with the twins bawling with the hunger...?" (32). He was forced into a dilemma, having to choose between whether to disobey his mother's orders to remain at the playground with the babies or to follow directions, and in which case, steal food for the twins.
Sin is blatantly evident in Malachy's selfishness and greed as well. His family is obviously not his number one priority. "When the farm money is gone he rolls home singing and crying over Ireland and his dead children, mostly about Ireland" (95). McCourt purposely draws attention to the fact that his father puts even Ireland before his family. He cries most over Ireland, not his dead children. He seems to be more concerned with his own self-pity and unfortunate life than that of the children which he inflicted with the same life. He claims that "he'd never stoop so low as to ask a farmer for anything" (95), yet he doesn't mind allowing his own greed to interfere with the well-being of his family.
The overall atmosphere of Frank McCourt's childhood is so dreary and downtrodden that this quote seems to fit it perfectly. He has nothing really to call his own and he is aware that his parents cannot, and do not, do much to help. Angela is so caught up in her own depression that she can hardly take the time to nurture and properly care for her children and Malachy is more consumed with his own problems.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Wow, I was truly impressed by the depth of your writing! I really think you did a solid job writing your blog, and I really liked how you picked strong quotes to go along with your strong writing! I also can tell that you really did some research about the differences between North and South Ireland. This is a very crucial factor because yes there were some major discrimination factors especially regarding religion. You did a great job going into depth about supporting why the mcCourt family suffered with sin and poverty. They truly had a horrible and very disgraceful life, and I believe you thoroughly explained this paralell that you noted! Great Job!
You write, "The overall atmosphere of Frank McCourt's childhood is so dreary and downtrodden..."
What do you think caused Frank to move beyond his dreary and downtrodden environment? How was he able to become a successful teacher and writer? What has McCourt taught us?
I think the prospect of America's social mobility greatly allowed for his success in the United States. The more liberal and open-minded U.S. was more accomodating and accepting at the time than Ireland and McCourt took that opportunity to his advantage. I believe McCourt has taught us the downfalls of a social hierarchy; what one can miss out on by having an err of superiority. His humor and ability to see the whole picture allowed for his success as well.
Post a Comment